TFW2005HisstankTokuNationToyark
The Toyark - News - Welcome to The Toyark!
The Chosen Prime
  • Home
  • News
    • Marvel Toy News
    • DC Toy News
    • Star Wars Toy News
    • Video Game Toy News
    • Dragonball Z Toy News
    • MOTU Toy News
    • San Diego Comic Con
    • Toy Fair
    • All News Categories…
  • JUMP OFF!
    • S.H.F Dragonball Z
    • Toy Fair Round Up
    • NYCC Round Up
    • SDCC Round Up
  • Photo Shoots
  • Forum
    • New Posts
    • News and Rumors
    • Action Figure GD
    • Marvel Forum
    • Customs
    • Fan Art
    • Collection Showcase
    • Buy Sell Trade
  • Companies
    • Tamashii Nations
    • McFarlane
    • Hasbro
    • NECA
    • Mezco
    • Super7
    • Mattel
    • Diamond Select Toys
    • Storm Collectibles
    • Hot Toys
    • Sideshow
  • Characters
    • Spider-Man
    • Iron Man
    • Batman
    • Superman
    • Wolverine
    • Hulk
    • Green Lantern
    • Captain America
    • Boba Fett
  • Scale
    • 3.75 Inch
    • 6 Inch
    • 7 Inch
    • 1/6
  • Sub-Lines
    • SH Figuarts
    • DC Multiverse
    • Marvel Legends
    • Black Series
    • Super7 Ultimates
    • One:12 Collective
    • Vintage Collection
    • Masterverse
    • MOTU Origins
Premium Bandai Dragon Ball
The Toyark › Toyark Spotlight › Discussion Of The Week Recap – Marvel vs DC

Discussion Of The Week Recap – Marvel vs DC

Posted on August 30, 2009 at 11:06 am by Joe Moore under Toyark Spotlight

Last weeks Toyark Discussion of the Week had a great turnout. Our members are very passionate about their love of comic based toys. Most of the posters sided with Marvel. A few of our members went against the grain and sided with DC. Here is a sampling of what people said on the subject of Marvel vs DC toys.

ludovicotek

I’m a Marvel guy, myself, so I lean heavily towards that direction. However, DC Direct has done a fantastic job of producing figures based on specific artist interpretations of characters. The DC Universe Classics line is great and reminds me of being a kid and playing with the Super Powers line. The 3.75″ stuff is just not on par with Marvel’s.

In the end I have to go with Marvel. From the original Secret Wars line, 90’s Marvel, X-Men and Spider-Man, Marvel Legends and now Marvel Universe, Marvel has consistently had great toys on store shelves that I always want to pick up.

deceptifocus

im a HUUUGE Marvel fan, but im thinking DC is actually putting some work into their 6″ line even tho there was a half a wave i couldnt find, im kind of tired of never seeing some of the marvel stuff and then only to be kind of dissapointed in some of it when i do find it. So to me its a draw, i love the DC figures but the personal attatchment to the characters isnt there, and well Hasbro has kinda been letting me down lately, i dont care for MU at all and so the lack of love for Legends is turning me off.

uberlad

I think DC would have won if this conversation was held before 1989. The Super Powers line was pure awesome, while Secret Wars was pretty cool, but not on the Super Powers level. From about 1990 on, Toy Biz took Marvel and expanded the universe to include 3 versions of every character ever made. Then there was the Spider-man Classics/Marvel Legends line which is one of the best toy lines ever. DCUC is cool, it’s just 8 years behind the pace, not to mention that the figures are impossible to find with any regularity.

I don’t need ot get into the 3 3/4 lines.

Make mine Marvel!

Ghost Story

Well I am DC guy all the way. I have every DC figure made in the US for the last 15 years, though in the last 5 years I have back way off of repaints or the weird named batman figures. Even the sorry ToyBiz ones with eh DC superheroes Aquaman that was so bad that wrote on the card back that he had to have armor under his shirt to keep him wet ( which did happen in the comics way back but not because his chest was three times the proportion of his body)

But this is because I like DC. I have to say that come of the marvel figs look amazing. Some look twisted in enough to be in the infinite heroes line if they were shorter.

The Marvel 3 3/4 quarter line far surpasses the DCIH line really in every way but scope. But I am really hoping that they catch up and Have already made up my mind if I have to re-buy every figure to get new better sculpts.

We do need accessories though badly for all of the DC lines. And some vehicles. The Batmobile and Supermobile being chief among them.

But to to put things into perspective….. If they made figures that looked like clayface with a bat of his chest… I would hunting them.

Thank you to everyone who participated. Look for the next discussion very soon.

Discuss on the Toyark Forums› Views: 4082

› Companies: Hasbro › Characters: Spider-Man

Discussion / Comments (Jump to this Thread on the Forum)

  1. Joe Moore's Avatar Joe Moore says

    08-24-2009, 07:52 AM

    Discussion Of The Week - Marvel Toys VS DC Toys

  2. Super_Megatron's Avatar Super_Megatron says

    08-24-2009, 08:32 AM

    I suspect a lot of people are going to say Marvel due to the successful launch of the Marvel Universe line. Personally I like more Marvel characters than DC characters so I feel my decision will be biased. The Marvel Legends and DC Universe Classics / Superheroes are all some nicely detailed toys. I've been fighting the urge to go crazy and buy a ton of these things in package at the local comic shops but will try and wait until the Canadian Action Figure Expo to pick some up loose.

    Ultimately I think Marvel is doing a better job of getting their 6 inch figures into stores. If you can't find the toy it's hard to collect it.

  3. Johnnyakiba's Avatar Johnnyakiba says

    08-24-2009, 08:39 AM

    Marvel. Do I need to explain why?

  4. trebleshot's Avatar trebleshot says

    08-24-2009, 09:22 AM

    I've always preferred the Marvel Universe characters over DC, with a few exceptions (Batman's Rogues Gallery). Also, I think Marvel has had better figures than DC, both in terms of availability and fun.

    My question would be what if Hasbro had the DC license and Mattel had the Marvel one? How would we feel then?

  5. ludovicotek's Avatar ludovicotek says

    08-24-2009, 09:23 AM

    I'm a Marvel guy, myself, so I lean heavily towards that direction. However, DC Direct has done a fantastic job of producing figures based on specific artist interpretations of characters. The DC Universe Classics line is great and reminds me of being a kid and playing with the Super Powers line. The 3.75" stuff is just not on par with Marvel's.

    In the end I have to go with Marvel. From the original Secret Wars line, 90's Marvel, X-Men and Spider-Man, Marvel Legends and now Marvel Universe, Marvel has consistently had great toys on store shelves that I always want to pick up.

  6. decepticon_mark's Avatar decepticon_mark says

    08-24-2009, 09:23 AM

    While I do prefer the way the Marvel figures are compared to the DC, I have to say Marvel BUT that decision is more based on the characters rather than the toys. I have read both Marvel and DC since I was old enough to read and truthfully I have more favorites in the Marvel Universe than the DC universe. So I say Marvel simply because in my opinion they have more interesting and fun characters than DC but that is of course an opinion and everyone is different.

  7. siamese goat has no avatar! siamese goat says

    08-24-2009, 09:57 AM

    I will play odd man out. I read the marvel books mainly because they are online but collect the DC Universe Classics. Mattel puts out a pretty solid figure.

  8. Snowflakian's Avatar Snowflakian says

    08-24-2009, 09:59 AM

    I'm an equal fan of both, and have always been a green lantern fan. With that said on the even characters...

    I tend to prefer the modern 3.75'' Marvel Figures. Better sculpts, better articulation, and just all around more poseable and fun. They also include accessories.

    DCIH which is my DC line of choice, while gradually improving the articulation, lacks accessories. I do give them kudos for doing jay garrick and other lower knowns so soon. But Lanterns without power batteries, female figures having v-cut legs, shoulder articulation and head rotation, just seems like they are still making DC figures in the 80s.
    Comparing Ms. Marvel to Raven/starfire/Star Saphire just isn't even fair. Ms. Marvel/Firestar are clear winners. Female sculpt with articulation that doesn't hinder detail that allows for a multitude of poses.

    So for now, I prefer Marvel, simply for the fair treatment they've given to all genders in sculpts and articulation.

    All that's for the 3.75'' lines though.

    When it comes to the collector lines...
    Marvel wins again. Legends has better bigger BAFs, better detail, and again, the better articulation. Mattel in the DC counterpart makes what looks to me like wrestling toys in DC costumes.

    It's only once we get over to the Direct figure market, that my opinion turns.
    While DC Direct is lacking somewhat in articulation they do make up for it in characters, regularity, and even a Green Lantern Specific line. Whereas Marvel Direct is slow with the characters, and hasn't done many to any characters I'd want.

    So I guess for me it boils down to this as the final result.

    3.75'' Winner: Marvel Universe. (Great sculpts, great articulation, no real gender bias on articulation.)
    6'' Winner: Marvel Legends. (Covers a wide array of characters with great articulation and massive BAFs)
    Direct Winner: DC (Multitude of lines covering all sorts of characters we may never see otherwise.)

    In the 90s, Kenner also surprised us with the Total Justice/JLA line. Great sculpts, low articulation, but the accessories made up for it. Compared to Toy Biz's marvel lines at the same time(this was right before legends), DC won flat out. Those were some of my favorite toys as I grew up reading the Kyle Rayner GL run. And though I watched and read X-Men back then, the figures in comparison were too basic and simple, with extremely low detail, and ugh, action features that hindered play value.
    Marvel has come a long way. It's a shame that DC has done an about face almost since they've switched companies. While they've improved the articulation, they just don't have that same sculpting magic they had back with Kenner. Even the duplicates that were released were amazingly neat figures, like the Flash Atom blue beetle three pack, or the Green Lantern Dr. polaris two pack.

    I'd like to see what Hasbro could manage now with the DC license after all they've done on MU. From the accessories to the poses and even the sculpts. It'd just be nice to have Blackest night, or Emerald Twilight, even Superman Red or Blue, or brainiac 13 like figures in those scales with faithful accurate detailed sculpts.

    So while I love me some green lantern. Marvel wins hands down for modern lines.
    But until X-Force X-23 is made, Mattel can still catch up if they overhaul some aspects of their DCIH lines. The new articulation is a great start. But they still need accessories, stands, and to correct the gender biased articulation. It sucks that starfire can't even make a decent flight pose. Or Raven a decent using her powers pose. Or even wonderwoman or more even being able to do a decent pose at all, or even stand without help. =/

  9. Joe Moore's Avatar Joe Moore says

    08-24-2009, 10:54 AM

    Wow, looks like this might be a first round KO.

  10. deceptifocus's Avatar deceptifocus says

    08-24-2009, 11:59 AM

    im a HUUUGE Marvel fan, but im thinking DC is actually putting some work into their 6" line even tho there was a half a wave i couldnt find, im kind of tired of never seeing some of the marvel stuff and then only to be kind of dissapointed in some of it when i do find it. So to me its a draw, i love the DC figures but the personal attatchment to the characters isnt there, and well Hasbro has kinda been letting me down lately, i dont care for MU at all and so the lack of love for Legends is turning me off

  11. G1Wheeljack's Avatar G1Wheeljack says

    08-24-2009, 12:46 PM

    For myself it has to be Marvel, as I collect 3 3/4" figures & I find the Universe/Fury Files to have much better articulation than DC's Infinite Hero's line while still having impressive sculpts. Also, some of the Marvel/TF Crossovers ain't to shabby.

  12. Shin Densetsu's Avatar Shin Densetsu says

    08-24-2009, 01:04 PM

    Quote:
    Ultimately I think Marvel is doing a better job of getting their 6 inch figures into stores. If you can't find the toy it's hard to collect it.
    Agreed. I was determined to be a completist with the DCUC line, but with wave 2 becoming like a Big Foot sighting, and me having rarely seen wave 3 and others, I gave up. The figures are great, I love them, the 4H make great figures, but now I just buy some if I see them.

    Both Marvel and DC toys are almost even at this point. How so? When one does a great line, the other does a poor one, and vice versa. For example, at this point, Marvel Universe dominates DC Infinite Heroes, and DCIH won't start catching up with more articulation until later this year. Marvel Legends was at it's strongest when Toy Biz launched it, but since Hasbro got the license, it had growing pains and is just now starting to become revitalized. Whereas DC Universe Classics has been consistently strong but suffers from the same problem that plagued Toy Biz' Marvel Legends line; they are hard to find with inconsistent distribution.

    Marvel tends to have better movie and cartoon figures, giving a broad range of toys to collect, be it for kids, collectors, or both. Their Marvel Crossovers Transformers are far superior to that of Mattel's transforming Batman robots as well.

  13. DamonJW has no avatar! DamonJW says

    08-24-2009, 01:30 PM

    For 3 3/4" Marvel is the clear winner; however for 6" I perfer DCUC. Up to series 4 there were quality issues to be sure, but the figures look great and display easily (at least for me). It is clear that Mattel cares about their 6" while the BigH could not care less, at least on a corporate level.

    No doubt in the past ToyBiz and to lesser extent did a great job with ML, but at least for now IMO DCUC is king...

    So for me: 3 3/4" Marvel; 6" DC

  14. uberlad's Avatar uberlad says

    08-24-2009, 03:12 PM

    I think DC would have won if this conversation was held before 1989. The Super Powers line was pure awesome, while Secret Wars was pretty cool, but not on the Super Powers level. From about 1990 on, Toy Biz took Marvel and expanded the universe to include 3 versions of every character ever made. Then there was the Spider-man Classics/Marvel Legends line which is one of the best toy lines ever. DCUC is cool, it's just 8 years behind the pace, not to mention that the figures are impossible to find with any regularity.

    I don't need ot get into the 3 3/4 lines.

    Make mine Marvel!

  15. Bariben35's Avatar Bariben35 says

    08-24-2009, 07:29 PM

    I to have liked both lines off and on favoring one over the other, but right now I really like the DCUC line. I regretfully agree though that they are annoyingly difficult to find with any consistency.

  16. crimsonguardvet has no avatar! crimsonguardvet says

    08-24-2009, 07:57 PM

    3&3/4-Marvel
    6"-DC
    Comics-Post-80s Crisis DC, Pre-90s Marvel

  17. CTO15 has no avatar! CTO15 says

    08-25-2009, 06:38 AM

    Marvel Legends was the 1st line that I really started collecting. With the new 2 packs being released, this has driven my love for them even more.

    the MU line was a nice distraction until ML came out again, but I can already tell that Hasbro is slowly transitioning us Marvel fans into the 3 3/4" scale.

    The DCUC brand has been amazing out of the gate; with their clever reuse of bodies, minor tooling to make some of the most obscure characters (B'Wanna Beast!) I love this line. I have to agree with distribution problems, especially since I'm Canadian that adds to not finding the current waves.


    If I had to choose one, I still have to give it to Marvel. Marvel was the 1st comic company that I started reading when I was a kid, so my heart lies there.

    But DCUC is right up there, so I can't totally dismiss the line.

  18. SirAutobotPrime has no avatar! SirAutobotPrime says

    08-25-2009, 11:39 AM

    This is a tough call, but I'm gonna have to go against most of the crowd and say DC, just because of the DCUC/SH line.

    Articulation plays a big part in my toy preferences, and while Marvel Legends is magical, some of the sculpts just aren't that pretty (Odd lookin' butt/neck joints etc). Also, the ball joints used in the hips seem to always stand out glaringly. This problem is less obvious in the 3.75" Marvel Universe line, which I have to admit I like and collect.

    But DCUC/SH doesn't have this problem with ball joints. And I love the sheer weight of story some of these DC characters have behind them (Any of the icons, the big 3--Supes, Bats, WW, for eg).

    It's strange about the distribution--here in South East Asia it's much easier to find DCUC and even DCSH stuff right now. We got lots of Marvel Legends but it's the much older waves. But I think pretty soon we'll not even get the DCUC stuff cos the word among retailers is that the price is going up some US$3, and that's pushing the cost price for these sellers up too much.

    So DC for best line (cos really, DC Direct stuff is never concerned about articulation) and Marvel for consistently good stuff.

  19. Greenskar's Avatar Greenskar says

    08-25-2009, 02:29 PM

    I have only 1 DC figure in my posession (Rorschack) and I own almost every MU figure that's been released so far excep Iron Fist, which I decided to wait for the variant of (with an actual fist) and I also own several ML figures that I decided were must haves as well as a few of the Marvel Select figures; it's safe to say who I feel wins in this category.

    I'm a HUGE Marvel fan, I just find their characters to be more fun to read about and they've had me hooked since I was a kid. I do however love Batman, and Watchmen was great, but it ends there. I'll read a good DC book when it's recommended but nothing has ever made me just want to go out and purchase their figures afterward the way Marvel has with their stories.

  20. Ghost Story's Avatar Ghost Story says

    08-25-2009, 08:29 PM

    Well I am DC guy all the way. I have every DC figure made in the US for the last 15 years, though in the last 5 years I have back way off of repaints or the weird named batman figures. Even the sorry ToyBiz ones with eh DC superheroes Aquaman that was so bad that wrote on the card back that he had to have armor under his shirt to keep him wet ( which did happen in the comics way back but not because his chest was three times the proportion of his body)

    But this is because I like DC. I have to say that come of the marvel figs look amazing. Some look twisted in enough to be in the infinite heroes line if they were shorter.

    The Marvel 3 3/4 quarter line far surpasses the DCIH line really in every way but scope. But I am really hoping that they catch up and Have already made up my mind if I have to re-buy every figure to get new better sculpts.
    We do need accessories though badly for all of the DC lines. And some vehicles. The Batmobile and Supermobile being chief among them.
    But to to put things into perspective….. If they made figures that looked like clayface with a bat of his chest… I would hunting them.

  21. Optimatron has no avatar! Optimatron says

    08-26-2009, 08:24 AM

    From the Original Secret Wars line, the 90's X-men/Marvel/Spider-man line, Marvel Legends, Marvel Select, and now the Marvel Universe 3.75 line, I think Marvel figures have always beaten DC figures in quality, design, character-likeliness, and articulation.

    I'm a fan of both Publisher's as well, so I speak as a unbiased consumer.

  22. Prem1x's Avatar Prem1x says

    08-26-2009, 12:47 PM

    My comic collection leans about 10 Marvels to 1 DC pretty much because I enjoy Marvel characters more. Though if there is a good story line in DC I'm all over it.

    Action figure wise, DC characters seem to generally have sillier costumes, which keeps me from wanting to buy any. If the DCIH stuff were nicer, I'd probably buy some DC A-listers to beat up on with my MU.

    Marvel all the way.

  23. Syncorizon has no avatar! Syncorizon says

    08-27-2009, 01:06 PM

    The first action figures I ever collected were Kenner's Super Powers collection...and still have very fond memories of this line. While Mattel's Secret Wars line came out about this same time...the figures just weren't as fun for me as a child. The 90's saw Toy Biz take over with their marvel lines. The kenner DC entries around this time just didn't grab me...and I still don't like the animated style figures. Now, I was a big fan of marvel legends when they first came out...but as I think was mentioned above, the ball joints on the hips can range from okay to "Why does this guy have his testicles for hips?" Upon seeing Mattel's DCUC figures...I forgot all about Marvel Legends. They're about as perfect as I can expect an action figure to be. I'll also agree with what's been previously stated, the marvel universe 3 3/4 figures do kick ass when compared to DC's Infinite Heroes...but again in defense of DC...DC Direct's stuff, while not as articulated as they should be by now, makes up for it with scads of variety.

    So, I'll side with the dissenters and vote DC.

  24. CyberScream95's Avatar CyberScream95 says

    08-30-2009, 09:58 AM

    When it comes to movies, DC is better. But for toys, Marvel is superior. Why? 2 words: Marvel-Legends.

  25. torque94 has no avatar! torque94 says

    08-30-2009, 10:50 AM

    i am a fan of marvel but dc is top dog now that blackest night is out it only makes the 6 inch toys look good yes i know dcuc is hard to find but the find makes them worth it and marvel legends may have more possibility and better characters and a longer streak they just dont compare to a good 6 inch toy with only 22 points of awesome and tell me does marvel legends have air holes in their boxes?

  26. There are more replies on the Toyark Forums.

    Keep reading: Marvel Or DC Toys? - Page 2

    Not a member yet? Join The Toyark Now!

Join the Conversation! › Discussion Of The Week Recap – Marvel vs DC Discussion

Premium Bandai

Search

Hot on Amazon

Marvel Legends Series Thor: Love and Thunder Thor Action Figure 6-inch Collectible Toy, 3 Accessories Marvel Legends Series Thor: Love and Thunder Thor... $24.99
G.I. Joe Classified Series Zarana Action Figure 48 Collectible Premium Toys with Multiple Accessories 6-Inch-Scale with Custom Package Art G.I. Joe Classified Series Zarana Action Figure 48... $24.99
G.I. Joe Classified Series Dusty Action Figure 49 Collectible Premium Toys with Multiple Accessories 6-Inch-Scale with Custom Package Art G.I. Joe Classified Series Dusty Action Figure 49... $24.99
McFarlane Toys - DC Build-A 7IN Figures WV8 - Blackest Night - Kyle Rayner McFarlane Toys - DC Build-A 7IN Figures WV8 -... $24.99
McFarlane Toys - DC Build-A 7IN Figures WV8 - Blackest Night - Batman McFarlane Toys - DC Build-A 7IN Figures WV8 -... $24.99
McFarlane Toys - DC Build-A 7IN Figures WV8 - Blackest Night - DEATHSTORM McFarlane Toys - DC Build-A 7IN Figures WV8 -... $24.99
McFarlane Toys - DC Build-A 7IN Figures WV8 - Blackest Night - Superman McFarlane Toys - DC Build-A 7IN Figures WV8 -... $24.99
Marvel Legends Series Black Panther Legacy Collection Black Panther 6-inch Action Figure Collectible Toy, 3 Accessories Marvel Legends Series Black Panther Legacy... $24.99
Marvel Legends Series Black Panther Legacy Collection Killmonger 6-inch Action Figure Collectible Toy, 5 Accessories Marvel Legends Series Black Panther Legacy... $24.99
McFarlane Toys - Mortal Kombat 7IN Figures - Commando Spawn McFarlane Toys - Mortal Kombat 7IN Figures -... $19.99
McFarlane Toys Spawn Action Figures Deluxe Box Set McFarlane Toys Spawn Action Figures Deluxe Box Set $39.96
DC Multiverse Batman (Rebirth) 7' Action Figure with Accessories DC Multiverse Batman (Rebirth) 7" Action Figure... $19.87
Tamashi Nations - Doctor Strange in The Multiverse of Madness - Doctor Strange (Doctor Strange in The Multiverse of Madness), Bandai Spirits S.H.Figuarts Tamashi Nations - Doctor Strange in The Multiverse... $84.00
Tamashi Nations - Spider-Man: Now Way Home - Spider-Man (Upgraded Suit), Bandai Spirits S.H.Figuarts Tamashi Nations - Spider-Man: Now Way Home -... $80.00
Tamashii Nations - The Batman - Batman (The Batman), Bandai Spirits S.H.Figuarts Action Figure Tamashii Nations - The Batman - Batman (The... $90.00
Tamashi Nations - Star Wars: The Mandalorian - Ronin Mandalorian & Grougu (Beskar Armor), Bandai Spirits MEISHO Movie Realization Tamashi Nations - Star Wars: The Mandalorian -... $157.96
SH Figuarts Dragon Ball Reference Guide
Extreme Sets Dioramas
San Diego Comic Con
New York Toy Fair
Beasts of the Mesozoic

Cool Stuff Around Toyark

NECA Galleries
Black Series Galleries
SHF Dragon Ball Galleries
One:12 Galleries
Realization Galleries
MOTU Galleries
DC Galleries
Marvel Galleries
Marvel Legends
Marvel One:12 Collective
Marvel S.H. Figuarts
Marvel Hot Toys
Star Wars Black Series
Star Wars 3.75
Star Wars Hot Toys
S.H. Figuarts
One:12 Collective
DC Comics Multiverse
Vitruvian H.A.C.K.S.
Mythic Legions
Robo Force
The Toy Source

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 7:15 PM.